The freshmen-led West Virginia team stunned Georgia--playing in what amounted to a home game in the Georgia Dome--by opening a 21-0 lead by the end of the first quarter. While West Virginia pushed the lead to 28-0 a minute into the second quarter, Georgia rallied to close the gap to 31-21 at halftime, behind quarterback D.J. Shockley. The 52 first-half points were a record for a single half in a BCS game.
In the third quarter, Georgia cut the lead to 31-28 following a 68-yard scoring drive.
Freshman quarterback Pat White led West Virginia on a 9-play, 95-yard drive to extend its lead to 38-28 with 8:32 remaining in the game. Georgia responded with a 90-yard drive of its own to cut the lead to 38-35 with 5:13 left.
With 1:26 remaining in the game and facing a 4th-and-6 near midfield, West Virginia's Phil Brady ran for 10 yards on a fake punt to seal the win. West Virginia's freshman running back Steve Slaton was named the game's MVP, having rushed for a Sugar Bowl-record 204 yards and 3 touchdowns, including two separate scores of 52-yards each. Fellow freshman Darius Reynaud, a wide receiver, scored the Mountaineers' other two touchdowns.