1909 College Football All-America Team

The 1909 College Football All-America team is composed of various organizations that chose College Football All-America Teams that season. The organizations that chose the teams were Collier's Weekly selected by Walter Camp, Leslie's Weekly, and the New York Evening Telegram.

Key

 * WC = Collier's Weekly as selected by Walter Camp
 * NYT = New York Times
 * TC = Tommy Clark, noted sports writer whose work appeared in several papers
 * UP = United Press consensus All-American team, based on selections from 22 of "the best football experts"
 * Bold - Consensus All-American
 * 1 - First Team Selection
 * 2 - Second Team Selection
 * 3 - Third Team Selection

Ends

 * Adrian Regnier, Brown (WC-1; NYT-1; TC-1)
 * John Kilpatrick, Yale (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; NYT-1; TC-1; UP-1)
 * L. Smith, Harvard (WC-2)
 * Bankhart, Dartmouth (WC-2; NYT-2)
 * Braddock, Penn (WC-2)
 * Harlan Page, Chicago (WC-3)
 * Frank McCaffrey, Fordham (WC-3)
 * Vaughan, Yale (NYT-2)

Tackles

 * Hamilton Fish III, Harvard (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; NYT-1; TC-1; UP-1)
 * Henry Hobbs, Yale (WC-1; NYT-1; UP-1)
 * James Walker, Minnesota (TC-1)
 * Lilley, Yale (WC-2; NYT-2)
 * McKay, Harvard (WC-2)
 * Rudolph Siegling, Princeton (WC-3)
 * William Casey, Michigan (WC-3)
 * Pullen, Army (NYT-2)

Guards

 * Albert Benbrook, Michigan   (WC-1)
 * Hamlin Andrus, Yale (WC-1; NYT-1; TC-1; UP-1)
 * William Goebel, Yale (WC-2)
 * Clark Tobin, Dartmouth (WC-2; NYT-1; TC-1; UP-1)
 * L. Withington, Harvard (WC-3)
 * Fisher, Harvard (WC-3; NYT-2)
 * Waller, Princeton (NYT-2)

Centers

 * Carroll Cooney, Yale (WC-1; NYT-1; TC-1; UP-1)
 * P. Withington, Harvard (WC-2; NYT-2)
 * H.E. Farnum, Minnesota (WC-3)

Quarterbacks

 * John McGovern, Minnesota (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; TC-1)
 * Arthur Howe, Yale (WC-2)
 * Earl Sprackling, Brown (WC-3; NYT-1; UP-1)
 * Page, Chicago (NYT-2)

Halfbacks

 * Stephen Philbin, Yale (WC-1; UP-1; NYT-2)
 * Wayland Manning Minot, Harvard (WC-1; NYT-1 [fb]; TC-1; UP-1 [fb])
 * Dave Allerdice, Michigan (WC-2; NYT-1; TC-1)
 * Joe Magidsohn, Michigan (WC-2)
 * Hamilton Corbett, Harvard (WC-3)
 * Red Miller, Notre Dame (WC-3)
 * Frothingham, Harvard (NYT-2)

Fullbacks

 * Ted Coy, Yale (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; NYT-1 [hb]; TC-1; UP-1 [hb])
 * Marks, Dartmouth (WC-2)
 * George McCaa, Lafayette (WC-3; NYT-2)