1958 College Football All-America Team

The 1958 College Football All-America team is composed of college football players who were selected as All-Americans by various organizations and writers that chose College Football All-America Teams for the 1958 college football season. The organizations choosing the teams included the United Press, Associated Press, Time, and the Newspaper Editors Association.

Ends

 * Buddy Dial, Rice (AP, UPI, NEA, WC, FWAA, TSN, Time)
 * Sam Williams, Michigan State (UPI, WC, AFCA, Time)
 * Jim Houston, Ohio State (AP, CP, FWAA)
 * Al Goldstein, North Carolina (NEA, FWAA)
 * Jim Wood, Oklahoma State (AFCA)
 * Curtis Merz, Iowa (FWAA)
 * Tom Franckhauser, Purdue (CP)
 * Monty Stickles, Notre Dame (TSN)

Tackles

 * Ted Bates, Oregon State (AP, UPI, NEA, CP, WC, AFCA, TSN)
 * Brock Strom, Air Force (AP, UPI, WC)
 * Jim Marshall, Ohio State (TSN, Time)
 * Ron Luciano, Syracuse (CP, NEA)
 * Bill Leeka, U.C.L.A. (Time)
 * Andrew Cvercko, Northwestern (FWAA)
 * Don Floyd, TCU (FWAA)
 * Vel Heckman, Florida (FWAA)
 * Gene Selawski, Purdue (FWAA)
 * Hogan Wharton, Houston (AFCA)

Guards

 * John Guzik, Pittsburgh (UPI, NEA, WC, FWAA, TSN, Time)
 * Zeke Smith, Auburn (AP, NEA, CP, WC, FWAA, Time)
 * George Deiderich, Vanderbilt (AP, AFCA, FWAA)
 * Al Ecuyer, Notre Dame (UPI, CP, TSN)
 * Bob Novogratz, Army (FWAA)
 * John Wooten, Colorado (AFCA)

Centers

 * Bob Harrison, Oklahoma (AP, UPI, NEA, CP, WC, FWAA, TSN)
 * Jackie Burkett, Auburn (AFCA, Time)
 * Max Fugler, LSU (FWAA)

Quarterbacks

 * Randy Duncan, Iowa (AP, UPI, NEA, CP, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN)
 * Joe Kapp, California (FWAA, Time)
 * Don Meredith, SMU (FWAA)

Halfbacks

 * Billy Cannon, LSU (AP, UPI, NEA, CP, WC, AFCA, FWAA TSN, Time)
 * Pete Dawkins, Army (AP, UPI, NEA, CP, WC, AFCA, FWAA, TSN)
 * Dick Bass, Pacific (Time)
 * Bob Anderson, Army (FWAA)

Fullbacks

 * Bob White, Ohio State (UPI, NEA, CP, WC, FWAA, TSN, Time)
 * Nick Pietrosante, Notre Dame (AFCA, FWAA)
 * Bill Austin, Rutgers (AP)

Key

 * Bold = Consensus All-American
 * AP = Associated Press
 * UPI = United Press International
 * NEA = Newspaper Enterprise Association
 * CP = Central Press Association
 * WC = Walter Camp Football Foundation
 * AFCA = American Football Coaches Association
 * FWAA = Football Writers Association of America
 * TSN = The Sporting News
 * Time = Time Magazine

Heisman Trophy voting
The chart below reflects the point total in the 1958 Heisman Trophy voting.